Skip to content

Demo site we built and broke on purpose. Not a client account.

A real tracking audit, in full.

We built a lead-gen site for a fictional plumbing company, broke its tracking the ways real sites break, and audited it with the same checklist we use on every account. Every number below comes from test leads we submitted by hand.

Only changes this page in your browser. Nothing is saved or sent.

YAYour Agency
REPORT DEMO-001

Conversion tracking audit

Brightline Plumbing

brightline-demo site · November 2026

Website
WordPress, 2 forms, booking widget
Ads
Google Ads, Meta Ads
Tracking
GTM, GA4, Pixel, CAPI plugin
CRM
HubSpot

8

findings

1

critical

5.8 hr

to fix all

Prepared by Your Agency. Type your agency name to rebrand this cover.

Live scanner · Step one of the audit

Run the first checks on your client's site.

This is the automated first pass of the audit: it reads the page source for tags, IDs, consent and forms. The full audit then tests real submissions in the accounts.

We fetch the HTML of that one page from our server and read it. No JavaScript runs, nothing is submitted, and we don't store the address or the results. Scan the landing page your ads point to for the most useful read.

01 · Executive summary

What the client's numbers were really saying.

TRACKING HEALTH

54

/ 100

Bidding on both platforms was learning from inflated numbers, and the CRM couldn't say where a single lead came from.

Score from our checklist: each conversion path tested in every destination, weighted by how much it distorts bidding and reporting.

LEADS RECORDED · DEMO TEST

We submitted 20 real test leads. Each platform should show 20.

  • Google Ads31+11

    Reloads and the back button counted again

  • Meta37+17

    Pixel and server both counted, no deduplication

  • GA411−9

    AJAX contact form never sent generate_lead

  • HubSpot, with source0−20

    Leads arrived as 'Direct traffic'

the real number: 20 leads

  • GOOGLE ADS

    Duplicates, calls missing

    F1 · F5 · F7

  • META

    Leads counted twice

    F2

  • GA4

    Half the form leads missing

    F3 · F6

  • HUBSPOT

    No source on any lead

    F4

  • GTM

    Cluttered, mixed naming

    F8

02 · Signal map

Every lead path, every destination.

One row per way a lead can arrive. One column per place it should be counted. Flip the switch to see the same grid after the fixes.

  • Quote form (/thank-you)

    Google Ads
    Duplicated
    Meta
    Duplicated
    GA4
    Once
    HubSpot
    No source
  • Contact form (AJAX)

    Google Ads
    Missing
    Meta
    Duplicated
    GA4
    Missing
    HubSpot
    No source
  • Call button (mobile)

    Google Ads
    Missing
    Meta
    n/a
    GA4
    Missing
    HubSpot
    n/a
  • Booking widget

    Google Ads
    Once
    Meta
    Once
    GA4
    Wrong source
    HubSpot
    No source
  • Once
  • Duplicated
  • Missing
  • Wrong source
  • No source
  • n/a

03 · Findings

Eight findings, ordered by what costs the client most.

Each one has the evidence we saw, why it matters, the fix and how we proved the fix works. Open any finding to see it.

  1. Evidence

    Tag Assistant: 'Ads – Submit lead form' fires on Page View where Page Path equals /thank-you. Reloading the page fires it again; so does the browser back button.

    Why it matters

    Every reload counts as a new lead, so Smart Bidding learns from conversions that never happened and the client's cost per lead looks better than it is.

    The fix

    Fire the conversion on the form plugin's success event pushed to the data layer, not on the page view, and set the conversion action to count 'One' per click.

    Data layer push on form success
    window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
    window.dataLayer.push({
      event: "lead_submitted",
      form_name: "quote_form",
      lead_id: "a8f3c1e2" // one ID per submission
    });

    Verified: Submitted, reloaded twice and pressed Back: Tag Assistant shows one conversion.

04 · Fix plan

All eight fixes, in the order that matters. About 5.8 hr of work.

  1. Step 11.5 hr

    Stop the bad data

    Bidding is learning from fake conversions right now. Fix these first.

  2. Step 22.3 hr

    Fill the gaps

    Real leads that no platform hears about.

  3. Step 31.5 hr

    Connect revenue

    So deals can be traced back to campaigns, and fed back to bidding.

  4. Step 40.5 hr

    Tidy up

    Makes the next change safe.

05 · Method

Tested, never assumed.

A dashboard can say a tag is installed. Only a real submission shows whether it fires once, on the right action, with the right data. So that's what we do, on every path.

  • GTM Preview
  • Tag Assistant
  • GA4 DebugView
  • Meta Test Events
  • HubSpot records
  • Chrome DevTools
  1. 01Submitted real test leads through every form, button and widget
  2. 02Watched which tags fired, and when, in GTM Preview
  3. 03Checked events and parameters in GA4 DebugView
  4. 04Confirmed Ads conversions in Tag Assistant
  5. 05Read Meta Test Events and deduplication
  6. 06Opened each HubSpot contact for source and UTM fields
  7. 07Tested desktop and mobile, with and without ad-click parameters
  8. 08Reloaded, pressed Back and double-submitted to catch duplicates

06 · Verification log

After the fixes: every path re-tested.

The test log you'd receive has a screenshot behind every row. Switch to “After fixes” at the top to compare with the signal map.

  • generate_leadQuote form, /thank-youGA4OnceGoogle AdsOnceMetaOnceHubSpot sourcegoogle / cpc
  • generate_leadContact form, AJAXGA4OnceGoogle AdsOnceMetaOnceHubSpot sourcefacebook / paid
  • phone_calltel: click, mobileGA4OnceGoogle AdsOnceMetan/aHubSpot sourcen/a
  • book_appointmentBooking widget, cross-domainGA4OnceGoogle AdsOnceMetaOnceHubSpot sourcegoogle / cpc

07 · What you receive

Everything you need to show the client, under your name.

  • The report

    This document, under your agency's name if you want: findings, evidence, fixes.

  • A walkthrough video

    3–5 minutes on screen, so you can explain it to the client without us.

  • The test log

    Every path, every destination, with the screenshots behind each row.

  • GTM change notes

    What changed, in which container version, and why.

  • Handover notes

    Enough for the next person to maintain it without guessing.

Branded as Your Agency. We never contact your client.

08 · Cost

What this would cost for a client account

The first look is a free tracking check. Seven of the eight fixes fall within Essentials at $390. Getting click IDs into HubSpot is CRM attribution, so fixing all eight is Revenue Connected at $890. Add monitoring from $99 a month if the site changes often.

See full pricing

Want this for one of your accounts?

Send us the account that doesn't add up. We review it for free and send a short video. The full report can carry your agency's name.